Huawei’s Car Subsidies Spark Controversy in China’s EV Market

WIRED reached out to Huawei about its role in subsidies, but Huawei did not respond before the article's publication.
Some Cities in China Are Advertising Exclusive Subsidies for Huawei-Powered Cars

As the electric vehicle (EV) industry in China becomes increasingly competitive, Huawei’s involvement in cutting-edge autonomous driving technology has taken center stage. Recently, government-backed subsidies have emerged, potentially reshaping the landscape for both automakers and consumers.

In March, the Commerce Bureau of Shenzhen Longgang District initiated one of the earliest subsidies, offering local car buyers up to 4,000 RMB (approximately $560) for purchasing a vehicle featuring Huawei’s driver-assistance system. The program, totaling a budget of 14,000,000 RMB, was designed to benefit over 3,500 local residents on a first-come, first-served basis. This was just the beginning.

By May, similar announcements were made by commerce bureaus across various provinces and municipalities in China. These bureaus, acting as consumer regulators, manage the distribution of government subsidies. They play a crucial role in implementing China’s broader economic strategy, which includes a nationwide program encouraging the trade-in of outdated electronics and vehicles to stimulate economic activity. The subsidies associated with Huawei’s technology were presented in a manner closely resembling official government welfare initiatives.

In some instances, such as in Henan and Anhui provinces, the subsidies were instead publicized by provincial auto industry associations. Despite these groups being private, the use of official-looking letterheads and red stamps lent an air of authenticity to their announcements.

Huawei’s pivot from its beleaguered global smartphone business, impacted by American trade restrictions, is notable. The tech giant has diversified by developing the Harmony operating system for various devices and exploring new frontiers in large language models and autonomous driving technologies, riding the wave of the AI boom.

While Huawei has pledged never to manufacture cars themselves, unlike competitors such as Xiaomi, they have established partnerships with several Chinese auto manufacturers. Huawei’s autonomous driving technology is particularly appealing to these companies, offering a “technically brand-agnostic” solution. According to Tu, Huawei’s technology is attractive to brands struggling to keep pace with intelligent driving advancements. “Effectively, if you’re desperate and you can’t keep up, you should partner with Huawei in the China market,” he explains.

The introduction of these subsidies has sparked debate within China, as they appear to favor certain brands in an already fiercely competitive EV market. As domestic market saturation forces Chinese EV brands to reduce prices and offer additional incentives to consumers, the central government has urged carmakers to avoid aggressive pricing strategies. Ilaria Mazzocco, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, noted, “For consumers, this is fantastic right now, but it just isn’t sustainable in the long term.”

In response to government pressure, companies may be exploring innovative strategies to enhance affordability, while local governments view Huawei’s self-driving technology as aligned with national objectives for high-tech manufacturing and AI self-sufficiency.

Prior to this year, similar Huawei car subsidies were scarce, with only one identified in 2022. At that time, Shenzhen offered a $1,400 subsidy per car for vehicles equipped with HarmonyOS. Huawei has remained silent regarding its financial involvement in these initiatives.

Original Story at www.wired.com