Michigan Supreme Court Declines to Hear Localities’ Appeal on Clean Energy Law
In a pivotal decision on Friday, the Michigan Supreme Court chose not to entertain an appeal from nearly 80 local governments challenging the state’s clean energy zoning law. The localities contended that state regulators had overstepped their bounds in applying the new policy.
Back in November 2024, 72 townships and seven counties filed a challenge against the Michigan Public Service Commission. They alleged that the commission had breached state rulemaking procedures by “unlawfully and unreasonably” altering key definitions and instituting processes that conflicted with the legislature’s clear intentions.
Governor Gretchen Whitmer had signed the Clean Energy and Jobs Act, including Public Act 233 and 234, nearly a year prior. These acts empowered the Michigan Public Service Commission to oversee permits for renewable energy and battery storage projects exceeding a certain size.
The Michigan Court of Appeals sided with the localities on two significant points, stating that the commission had erred in including only government units with zoning authority as “affected local units.” Furthermore, the timeline for notifying developers about a “compatible renewable energy ordinance” did not align with state law. Despite these findings, the court largely supported the commission’s implementation of the law.
In their appeal to the Michigan Supreme Court, the localities posed a singular question: Did the Public Service Commission exceed its authority in its October 10 order related to the permitting law? However, the high court ultimately declined to review the case, stating, “we are not persuaded that the question presented should be reviewed by this Court.”
Nonetheless, the Supreme Court’s order acknowledged some concerns brought forward in a cross-appeal by the Michigan Public Service Commission and clean energy advocacy groups. These points pertain to the Court of Appeals’ decisions on notification timelines and project progression in instances where local officials do not engage within specified timeframes. Oral arguments on these matters are set for January 2027.
Advanced Energy United, Clean Grid Alliance, and the Michigan Energy Innovation Business Council, who were involved in the case, expressed satisfaction with the court’s refusal to hear the local governments’ appeal, thus allowing the commission to advance with the permitting law’s implementation. Trish Demeter from Advanced Energy United remarked, “Michigan needs to generate more energy to keep energy costs down as demand continues to surge. The Clean Energy and Jobs Act ensures business leaders have certainty to invest in Michigan, building the projects that power the state’s grid and create jobs.”
Meanwhile, Foster Swift Collins and Smith, PC, representing the local governments, acknowledged their disappointment in the court’s decision but were pleased with the ruling on the definition of an “affected local unit.” Michael D. Homier from Foster Swift highlighted, “This is an important win for counties and other local governments that may not exercise zoning authority over a project site but will nevertheless experience the project’s impacts.”
The Michigan Public Service Commission expressed gratitude to the Supreme Court for clarifying the issues it will review, stating, “We look forward to making our case.”
Original Story at michiganadvance.com