In an unexpected twist, researchers exploring medieval burial practices in Denmark have unearthed evidence suggesting that society at the time may have been more compassionate than previously believed. Contrary to the expectation that individuals suffering from illnesses like leprosy were shunned in death as they were in life, findings show that these individuals were often laid to rest in prime burial locations alongside their healthier peers.
During the medieval era in Denmark, Christians would demonstrate their wealth by purchasing graves closer to the church. These high-status burial sites were typically reserved for those who could afford them, leading researchers to investigate whether individuals with chronic diseases, such as leprosy or tuberculosis, were excluded from these prestigious resting places. Surprisingly, data reveals that infected individuals were not barred from these areas.
“When we started this work, I was immediately reminded of the film Monty Python and the Holy Grail, specifically the scene with the plague cart,” stated Dr. Saige Kelmelis from the University of South Dakota, one of the lead authors of the study published in Frontiers in Environmental Archaeology. “Our study reveals that medieval communities were variable in their responses and in their makeup. For several communities, those who were sick were buried alongside their neighbors and given the same treatment as anyone else.”
Investigating Burial Sites
To better understand these burial practices, Kelmelis, alongside researchers Vicki Kristensen and Dr. Dorthe Pedersen from the University of Southern Denmark, analyzed 939 adult skeletons from five Danish medieval cemeteries, consisting of both urban and rural sites. This allowed them to observe potential differences in how these diseases were perceived between densely populated towns and the countryside.
Leprosy and tuberculosis, though both prevalent, impacted individuals differently. Leprosy, with its distinctive facial lesions, was more visible, whereas tuberculosis could remain asymptomatic for extended periods. “Tuberculosis is one of those chronic infections that people can live with for a very long time without symptoms,” Kelmelis explained.
By assessing each skeleton, researchers identified signs of these diseases and mapped the graves to identify any correlation with burial status. They looked for patterns indicating whether the presence of disease influenced the location of the burial, such as proximity to religious buildings.
“There is documentation of individuals being able to pay a fee to have a more privileged place of burial,” Kelmelis noted. This implies that wealth could secure a more favorable resting place, much like securing a pew closer to the altar during life.
The Reality of Medieval Stigma
The findings highlighted that, generally, there was no direct link between having a disease and burial status. An exception was noted at the urban cemetery of Ribe, where a higher rate of tuberculosis was observed in lower-status burials. However, this was interpreted as a reflection of varied exposure levels rather than societal stigma.
Intriguingly, the urban cemetery of Drotten displayed a significant number of prestigious burials with tuberculosis, suggesting that wealthier individuals, who could afford prime burial locations, might have had access to better living conditions, allowing them to live longer with the disease.
These insights challenge the stereotype of medieval societies as exclusionary towards the ill, although the researchers acknowledge the need for further excavation and analysis to fully understand these dynamics. “Individuals may have been carrying the bacteria but died before it could show up in the skeleton,” Kelmelis pointed out, emphasizing the limitations of the study.
Read and download original article
REPUBLISHING GUIDELINES: Open access and sharing research is part of Frontiers’ mission. Unless otherwise noted, you can republish articles posted in the Frontiers news site — as long as you include a link back to the original research. Selling the articles is not allowed.
Original Story at www.frontiersin.org