Exploring Why Humans Find Blackbirds’ Songs More Pleasant Than Owls’

Blackbirds' complex, high-pitched songs are rated most pleasant, signaling safe environments, unlike barn owls' calls.
Scientists discover the key ingredients that make birdsong pretty
A blackbird on Castle Hill, Budapest. Photograph by Balazs Szanto under Creative Commons licence CC-BY-SA 2.0

Birdsong has long been associated with tranquility and well-being, but a recent study delves deeper into why certain bird calls captivate us more than others. By examining the preferences for the calls of 123 bird species, scientists discovered that listeners favor intricate, high-pitched melodies that are not overly loud. Remarkably, blackbirds topped the charts in terms of pleasantness, while barn owls were less favored.

In an effort to understand what makes birdsong appealing, researchers invited participants to rate various bird calls. The findings revealed that the complexity and pitch of a song are crucial factors in its appeal. Interestingly, a person’s knowledge about birds did not influence their enjoyment, indicating an innate appreciation for birdsong beauty. According to the study, “You don’t have to be a ‘bird person’ to find bird sounds beautiful,” said Dr Nadine Kalb from the University of Tübingen, as noted in the Frontiers in Bird Science.

Acoustic Appeal

The researchers speculated that loudness might negatively impact a song’s pleasantness, while personal taste and knowledge could play roles. Dr Christoph Randler, senior author and bird enthusiast, noted, “Bird sounds are often considered one of the most enjoyable aspects of spending time in nature, and previous research has shown that they can contribute to psychological restoration and well-being.”

The study involved 84 participants who listened to brief clips from common German bird species. Participants rated each song’s pleasantness on a scale from one to five and completed surveys assessing their birding familiarity. Scientists analyzed the acoustic properties, such as amplitude, frequency, and complexity, and compared these with the participants’ ratings and their interest in birds.

Additionally, the study cross-referenced 21 species from previous research on the restorative qualities of birdsong. Analysis showed that birds with narrower bandwidths and higher frequencies, like the blackbird, were deemed more pleasant. Dr Kalb suggested, “We might be wired to prefer more variable sounds with moderate amplitudes and frequencies because they signal a safe, healthy, and restorative environment where we can relax.”

While the study highlights key components of birdsong appeal, researchers acknowledge the need for further exploration. Factors such as call frequency and broader demographic samples are areas for future research. Dr Randler expressed interest in examining how bird sounds affect real-world environments and the implications of biodiversity changes on human experiences.

REPUBLISHING GUIDELINES: Open access and sharing research is part of Frontiers’ mission. Unless otherwise noted, you can republish articles posted in the Frontiers news site — as long as you include a link back to the original research. Selling the articles is not allowed.

Original Story at www.frontiersin.org