Switching from Spotify to Apple Music: A Journey of Ethical Choices

After months of delay, I finally canceled Spotify, amidst concerns over ethics, poor artist pay, and more. Switching was daunting, but I opted for Apple Music despite its flaws, seeking the least worst option in streaming.
Ditching Spotify Has Been A Bleak Experience To Say The Least

The decision to switch music streaming services can often feel daunting, especially after years of curating playlists and favorite songs on one platform. Recently, an individual took the plunge, ending their Spotify subscription after a series of growing concerns, including the CEO’s controversial support of certain policies and issues such as poor artist compensation and company layoffs. The transition, however, was more than just a change of service; it was a reflection of the user’s broader efforts to align personal spending with ethical values.

Switching services wasn’t just about ethics; it was also about practicality. Having been loyal to streaming services for nearly 15 years, the individual was wary of the logistical hassle involved in transferring countless playlists and liked tracks. Their last attempt, moving from Google Play Music to Spotify after the former’s rebranding, had been fraught with issues and lost music.

Spotify now features AI band clones
by
u/Dipper_Pines in
Music

After witnessing everyone’s enthusiasm over their Spotify Wrapped results, the decision to quit became more pressing. The user was motivated by a broader initiative to support responsible and ethical consumer choices, having already adopted solar power, chosen ethical banking and superannuation providers, and switched to an electric vehicle.

The actual cancellation of Spotify was straightforward, albeit with one hiccup: their daughter, who used Spotify socially with her friends, objected. A compromise was reached by providing her with her own subscription, respecting her autonomy to make her own choices as she matures.

I found myself not looking for the best streaming platform, just trying to find the least worst.

The real challenge lay in selecting a new service. The family needed a platform compatible with their diverse devices and listening habits, including a Pixel phone, an iPhone, desktop listening, and a car with Google’s Android Automotive. YouTube Music was first considered, but its poor quality and app performance quickly disqualified it.

Exploring further options based on Brian Merchant’s guide and social media recommendations, they found each alternative lacking. Deezer didn’t appeal, Amazon Music was dismissed, and while Tidal offered higher artist pay and sound options, its app design was unconvincing.

been shopping for a spotify alternative this week and this is grim stuff. its either volatile small guys who will be dead or bought out in 18 months or trying to decide which major tech platform you hate the least

Luke Plunkett (@lukeplunkett.com) 2025-12-03T20:23:29.531Z

Ultimately, the choice narrowed down to two contenders: Apple Music and Qobuz. Qobuz excelled in artist compensation but was costly, especially considering concurrent YouTube Premium and Spotify subscriptions for the daughter. Additionally, its mobile app was subpar.

Apple Music, while not perfect, emerged as the most viable option. Although it lacked native car support and combined podcast features, it excelled in artist payment, audio quality, and app design. The transition was smooth, facilitated by a Soundiiz membership that transferred the entire library seamlessly.

This shift also brought unexpected benefits, like the return of beloved albums previously pulled from Spotify due to ethical protests. The individual acknowledges the conveniences of streaming remain alluring but remains mindful of the impact on artists.

The switch to Apple Music was more seamless than anticipated, yet it highlighted the broader challenge of balancing convenience with ethical consumption. The individual is aware that true support for artists may eventually mean moving away from streaming altogether.

How to quit Spotify

This Black Friday, here’s a guide to finding the best Spotify alternative

Original Story at aftermath.site