Examining the Unproven Promise of Carbon Capture and Climate Models

"Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is widely promoted for climate solutions, but evidence shows it underperforms."
A demonstrator holds up a large blue globe painted with a sad, crying face. They are standing amid protesters holding illuminated smartphones, flags and signs.

In an era of climate consciousness, words like “Carbon neutral,” “Net zero,” and “Climate pledge friendly” have become ubiquitous across industries. These terms promise a balance where carbon emissions from fossil fuels are offset through technologies like carbon capture and storage (CCS). However, the effectiveness of such measures is under scrutiny.

A recent investigation by journalists from ProPublica and Drilled has delved into the reliance on CCS technology, exploring how it aims to sequester carbon dioxide underground. This process is designed to prevent the gas from exacerbating global warming. The oil industry has been a strong proponent of this technology, and it has gained support from the United Nations as a viable solution on a large scale.

During the U.N.’s annual climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, global leaders discussed strategies to limit climate change. A key assumption in these discussions is that billions of tons of CO2 can be stored annually, potentially matching the scale of the global oil industry within decades. Yet, evidence supporting this expectation remains limited. Only 12 large-scale CCS projects exist, with several underperforming or failing, and the total CO2 sequestered last year was less than the emissions of a single large power plant.

Why does CCS continue to be a cornerstone of climate policy despite its unproven track record? It boils down to the models that policymakers use, which often assume the technology’s success. These models, built by powerful groups of experts, forecast scenarios where actions like transitioning to electric vehicles can mitigate severe climate impacts. If these models are incorrect, cities like Miami could face dire consequences.

An analysis comparing CCS projections with solar power shows the disparity: solar energy has far exceeded expectations, while CCS has not met projected targets. This raises questions about the assumptions underlying these models.

Challenges in CCS Modeling and Assumptions

Modelers often assume capturing carbon is straightforward, but real-world data suggests otherwise. Capture rates have been lower than industry promises, yet models predict up to a 92% success rate, factoring in incentives like carbon taxes and subsidies. Keywan Riahi from the Austrian model emphasizes that these incentives could improve capture rates, although current data suggests otherwise.

Furthermore, real-world CCS projects encounter practical issues not accounted for in models. For example, Chevron’s Gorgon plant, a major CCS operation, has faced operational challenges, leading to CO2 releases. Only the German model considers limits on CO2 injection, based on expert interviews rather than robust data.

Geological and Economic Assumptions

The assumption that Earth’s capacity for CO2 storage is limitless stems from a 2005 U.N. report influenced by petroleum interests. However, a recent study in Nature indicates that feasible storage space may be far more limited. If CCS were to expand as modeled, available storage could be depleted by the next century.

Another critical assumption is that stored CO2 remains secure indefinitely. However, leaks have occurred at large-scale sites, raising concerns about long-term efficacy. When asked if models account for such risks, Detlef van Vuuren, a Dutch model leader, simply responded, “Nope.”

Cost assumptions also diverge from reality. Models suggest CCS will become cheaper, but actual costs have risen. Jessica Strefler from the German model questions whether future generations will bear these costs, given current reluctance to fund CO2 reduction.

Overall, these models may overlook historical underperformance and economic realities, relying on optimistic assumptions and unreviewed sources. Despite this, some modelers, like van Vuuren, maintain that CCS should remain a consideration, contingent on policy decisions and investment willingness.

Ultimately, models function as blueprints for potential futures, illustrating scenarios where CCS could help achieve climate goals. However, as Riahi quipped, relying on unproven solutions is akin to hoping for an extraterrestrial fix: “You can quote me that I think carbon dioxide removal is more likely than an alien.”

Original Story at www.propublica.org