Nine EU Capitals Challenge Electric Vehicle Mandate for Corporate Fleets

Nine European capitals oppose an EU proposal mandating large corporate fleets switch to EVs, citing competitiveness concerns.
Nine EU countries rebel against EU's green targets for corporate cars and vans

The debate over electric vehicle adoption in Europe is intensifying as a group of nine European capital cities unites against a proposed mandate from the European Commission. This mandate would require large corporate vehicle fleets to transition to electric vehicles, sparking concerns among these cities about potential impacts on business competitiveness and infrastructure readiness.

In a coordinated response, Poland, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Slovakia, and Romania have voiced opposition to the proposal. The regulation targets companies with over 250 employees or a turnover exceeding €50 million, aiming to decarbonize their fleets by 2030.

Under the Commission’s plan, these companies would be obligated to meet ambitious quotas: approximately 69 percent of new vehicle purchases would need to be plug-in hybrids, while 45 percent would have to be battery-electric or hydrogen-powered. However, the specific targets would differ by member state.

The opposing governments recognize the critical role corporate fleets could play in reducing Europe’s reliance on imported oil, which currently constitutes nearly 60 percent of the bloc’s imports. Yet, they argue that mandatory quotas could undermine business competitiveness, suggesting that incentives, rather than regulations, would be more effective.

“Priority should be given to an enabling EU framework based on guidelines, exchange of best practices, targeted incentives, and technical support, rather than the proposed regulation,” the governments stated in their document.

Transport & Environment (T&E), a campaign group, highlighted the inadequacy of current tax incentives in 18 of 27 EU countries to counterbalance the higher costs of electric vehicles. According to Stef Cornelis, fleets and freight director at T&E, major car markets like Germany, Spain, Italy, and Poland are not sufficiently encouraging companies to switch to electric vehicles.

“The EU fleets regulation is the catalyst needed to break this inertia. The EU Council and EU Parliament should inject more ambition into the Commission’s proposal to ensure Europe can reduce oil imports rapidly,” said Cornelis.

Corporate-linked vehicles account for 59 percent of new car registrations and 78 percent of oil imports consumed, according to T&E. The dissenting governments also point to disparities among EU nations in terms of charging infrastructure, leasing markets, taxation systems, grid capacity, and administrative frameworks. They emphasize that a uniform target could disadvantage countries with less developed electrification ecosystems.

Avoiding collateral damage

While the regulation is aimed at large enterprises, the nine governments caution that it could inadvertently affect smaller businesses. Many SMEs rely on leasing rather than purchasing vehicles directly, meaning fleet requirements on leasing companies could extend to them.

“Covering leasing companies with targets, without exceptions for certain groups of their clients, would lead in practice to exposing SMEs to these targets,” the document states, highlighting that about 80 percent of vehicles used by SMEs are leased.

Furthermore, the coalition argues for greater flexibility for special-purpose vehicles and fleets associated with critical infrastructure and emergency services. They insist that operational readiness should not be compromised for climate goals.

“The greening of corporate fleets should also be pursued in a manner consistent with the Union’s broader objectives of resilience, emergency preparedness, and economic security, particularly in light of the current geopolitical situation,” they assert in their document.

Original Story at www.euronews.com